
A growing article library should help customers answer more questions, not ask them to read the same answer repeatedly. Before expanding it, identify the purpose and contribution of each proposed page. A publishing schedule is most useful when it follows a clear audience need and an accountable editorial process.
Reconstructed archive: March 2024. Written in November 2026 using contemporary historical sources. The archive date organizes this series; this text is not a recovered original.
The March 2024 announcement
On March 5, 2024, Google announced a core update and new spam policies, including scaled content abuse. The policy addressed content produced at scale primarily to manipulate rankings, regardless of whether people or automation created it. Volume and production method alone were not a useful editorial quality test.
Give each article a distinct job
Read the complete page and name the question it answers before deciding what to change. Compare it with other pages serving that same question. A related topic alone is not enough reason to merge two useful explanations.
Keep one audit record per URL:
- Reader task: who needs the page and what decision or action it helps them complete.
- Contribution: the original explanation, approved project evidence, useful example or method it provides.
- Currency: which service facts or technical claims need checking, and which material is intentionally historical.
- Overlap: the exact other page and the answer repeated, plus any distinct value either page would lose in a merger.
- Business relevance: the service, customer question or support need the page serves.
- Known URL evidence: available visits, inquiries, search information and incoming links, with their source and period. Record unavailable values as unknown, not zero.
- Decision and verification: keep, improve, propose a merge or develop a distinct new page; name the owner, specific work and completion check.
A library can grow when an underserved reader task deserves its own answer and the business has something useful to contribute. Define that purpose before commissioning another page. Neither expansion nor consolidation needs an arbitrary article count or word target.
Contribute specific knowledge
Use accurate business explanations, practical tradeoffs, and verified sources. Avoid invented experience or unsupported performance claims. A historical article should make its period and reconstruction context clear so readers can distinguish contemporary commentary from instructions intended for use today.
Review beyond the publishing checklist
The following decisions are hypothetical examples, not findings about particular Guardian pages:
- Keep: a specialist preparation guide answers a distinct customer question and contains accurate, approved instructions. Low traffic alone is not a deletion reason.
- Improve: a service article answers a useful question but omits a practical limitation or contains an outdated process step. Correct that specific gap and verify the live answer.
- Propose a merge: two pages answer the same question with substantially repeated guidance. Compare their complete bodies and known URL evidence, choose a relevant survivor and transfer every useful distinction and approved proof before proposing retirement.
- Develop a new page: recurring customer questions concern a different decision that existing pages cannot answer well within their purpose. Give the new page its own brief, evidence and useful next step.
Google’s people-first guidance emphasizes useful, original answers rather than preferred word counts or changing dates to appear fresh. Its scaled-content policy concerns pages produced primarily to manipulate rankings without helping users. The mere number of pages, or the use of a drafting tool, does not settle this editorial decision.
Keep the library maintainable
Assign each agreed change to an owner and record what a successful revision must preserve. Keep approved result numbers, project context, dates, qualifications, source links and image permissions intact. If an underlying report is unavailable, flag the verification gap for review rather than silently discarding a previously approved result. Our content evidence review provides a way to record that context.
Before an approved merge removes a URL, confirm that the survivor answers the old link’s purpose, retains the useful material and has been checked live. Plan the relevant redirect, update known internal links and sitemap entries, and retain a recoverable record. Do not send every retired article to the homepage or retire a page solely because it appears in an indexing exclusion report.
Check the published result: the promised answer remains clear, citations and assets still work, and the intended next step is available. Keep honest publication and modification dates, including reconstruction disclosures. When a traffic decline is the concern, use the separate traffic-loss diagnosis before assuming that rewriting or reducing the library is the remedy.
Explore website design, digital marketing strategy, or contact Guardian Solutions to discuss your next step.
Historical source: Google announcement dated 2024-03-05.
